A 4-Year Dollar-Cost Averaging Experiment: Crypto vs. Stocks

·

Have you ever bought a stock at what seemed like a low price, only to watch it fall further, leaving your investment stuck? It’s a frustrating experience. What if there was a simpler, more systematic way to invest that could reduce risk and improve your chances of success? There is—it’s called dollar-cost averaging (DCA).

Dollar-cost averaging is an investment strategy where you invest a fixed amount of money at regular intervals, regardless of market conditions. This approach removes the need to time the market. Instead of making one large investment, you spread your purchases over time, which can lower the average cost per share and reduce the impact of volatility.

This method is especially useful for new investors or those who prefer a more disciplined, hands-off strategy. It encourages consistent investing and helps avoid emotional decisions based on short-term price movements.

Table of Contents:

What Is Dollar-Cost Averaging?

Dollar-cost averaging (DCA) is a long-term investment strategy designed to mitigate risk. Instead of investing a lump sum all at once, you regularly invest smaller, fixed amounts. This means you buy more units when prices are low and fewer when prices are high, averaging out your entry price over time.

This strategy is ideal for volatile markets or assets that experience significant price swings. It takes the guesswork out of investing and helps build discipline, making it easier to stick to your financial plan.

Which Assets Are Best for DCA?

Not all assets are equally suited for dollar-cost averaging. The best candidates are those with strong long-term growth potential and relatively high volatility. Assets like major cryptocurrencies and blue-chip tech stocks often fit this profile.

Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum are known for their price fluctuations, which can make timing the market difficult. Similarly, tech stocks like those in the FAANG group (Facebook/Meta, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google) have shown strong historical performance but can be unpredictable in the short term.

DCA works well for these types of assets because it smooths out purchase prices and reduces the risk of investing a large amount right before a downturn.

The 4-Year Experiment: Setup and Parameters

To compare the performance of dollar-cost averaging in different asset classes, we set up a hypothetical experiment. The period analyzed was from June 2021 to May 2025—a total of four years. Each month, we invested $100 into a selected basket of assets.

The portfolios were divided into two groups:

We used a reliable investment calculator to simulate returns, assuming dividends were reinvested in the stock portfolio. The goal was to compare total returns, overall growth, and relative volatility between these two groups.

Cryptocurrency Performance Review

The cryptocurrency portfolio displayed notable performance over the four-year period. Bitcoin and Ethereum, being the largest cryptocurrencies by market cap, led the group with substantial gains. Solana also showed strong growth, though with higher volatility. XRP had more moderate returns.

Despite significant price swings—common in crypto markets—the consistent monthly investments helped average down costs during market dips. By the end of the period, the cryptocurrency basket yielded significantly higher returns compared to the tech stock portfolio.

This illustrates the potential of DCA when applied to high-growth, high-volatility assets like major cryptocurrencies.

Tech Stock Performance Review

The tech stock portfolio, consisting of Meta, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, and Google, delivered steady and respectable returns. These companies are established leaders with strong financials and continuous innovation.

While individual stock performance varied, the overall portfolio grew consistently. Netflix, for example, had periods of slower growth, while Apple and Amazon continued to perform well. Reinvesting dividends further enhanced compound returns.

However, when compared directly to the cryptocurrency portfolio, the tech stock returns were more modest. This isn’t surprising given the higher risk and reward profile of digital assets.

Final Comparison: Crypto vs. Stocks

After four years of monthly $100 investments, the two portfolios showed clear differences in performance. The cryptocurrency portfolio significantly outperformed the tech stock portfolio, with an approximate eightfold difference in total returns.

It’s important to note that this difference comes with higher risk. Cryptocurrencies are more volatile and can experience rapid downturns. Tech stocks, while still subject to market cycles, tend to be more stable.

This experiment highlights how asset choice impacts DCA results. Higher-risk assets may offer higher returns, but they require a greater tolerance for price fluctuations.

Risk Management and Final Thoughts

Dollar-cost averaging is a powerful strategy, but it’s not without risks. Market downturns can still lead to losses, especially if you need to withdraw funds in the short term. That’s why DCA is best used as part of a long-term plan.

Diversification is key. Instead of focusing on a single asset, consider spreading investments across different sectors or asset classes. This can help balance risk while still capturing growth.

It’s also important to stay informed and adjust your strategy as needed. Regular reviews of your portfolio can help you stay on track with your financial goals.

👉 Explore more investment strategies

Remember, no investment is entirely risk-free. Always do your own research and consider your financial situation before making investment decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is dollar-cost averaging?
Dollar-cost averaging is an investment strategy where you invest a fixed amount of money at regular intervals. This reduces the impact of market volatility and lowers the average cost of your investments over time.

Is DCA better than lump-sum investing?
It depends on your goals and risk tolerance. DCA reduces timing risk and is psychologically easier for many investors. Lump-sum investing may yield higher returns if the market rises immediately, but it also carries higher risk if the market falls.

Which assets are best for dollar-cost averaging?
Assets with high growth potential and volatility are well-suited for DCA. This includes major cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum, as well as high-growth tech stocks.

Can DCA guarantee profits?
No investment strategy can guarantee profits. DCA helps manage risk and smooth out purchase prices, but it does not eliminate the possibility of losses, especially in declining markets.

How long should I use a DCA strategy?
DCA is most effective as a long-term strategy. It’s ideal for investors with a time horizon of five years or more, allowing them to ride out market fluctuations.

Should I stop DCA during a market crash?
It’s often beneficial to continue DCA during market downturns. This allows you to buy more units at lower prices, which can improve your average entry price and potential long-term returns.