The launch of spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in the United States in early January 2024 marked a significant milestone for cryptocurrency investing. However, similar products known as physical Bitcoin exchange-traded products (ETPs) have been available on European exchanges since 2019. Both provide retail investors with a way to gain exposure to Bitcoin’s price movements without directly holding the cryptocurrency, but they differ in structure, regulation, and operational details.
What Are Exchange-Traded Products (ETPs)?
Exchange-traded products (ETPs) serve as a broad category that includes ETFs, exchange-traded commodities (ETCs), and exchange-traded notes (ETNs). These investment vehicles track the performance of an underlying asset—such as a stock, commodity, currency, or cryptocurrency—and trade on traditional stock exchanges. This accessibility allows investors to add Bitcoin exposure to their portfolios without needing to use decentralized crypto exchanges or manage private keys.
There are two primary types of ETPs:
- Physical (or Spot) ETPs: These hold the actual underlying asset (e.g., Bitcoin) in custody.
- Synthetic ETPs: These use derivatives and other financial instruments to mimic the asset’s performance, often introducing greater complexity and reduced transparency.
Physical ETPs rely on custodians—independent financial institutions responsible for safeguarding the assets. These custodians also facilitate trade settlement, ensuring secure and efficient transactions.
Overview of Spot Bitcoin ETFs
Spot Bitcoin ETFs are a specific type of exchange-traded fund that holds actual Bitcoin. The journey toward their approval in the U.S. began as early as 2013, with significant momentum building in 2023 when major financial firms like BlackRock and Fidelity submitted applications to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The SEC granted approval in January 2024, leading to substantial investor interest and inflows.
ETFs are structured as open-ended investment companies or trusts, pooling investor capital to purchase Bitcoin. They can create new shares to meet rising demand. Prominent providers use established custodians for asset security. For example:
- BlackRock uses Coinbase Prime, with assets stored in cold storage via Coinbase Custody Trust Company.
- Fidelity relies on its subsidiary, Fidelity Digital Assets, regulated by the New York Department of Financial Services.
These custodial solutions emphasize security through offline storage, institutional oversight, and regular audits.
Understanding Physical Bitcoin ETPs
Physical Bitcoin ETPs, commonly structured as exchange-traded commodities (ETCs), operate under a different framework. They are often bankruptcy-remote special purpose vehicles (SPVs), meaning they are separate legal entities with independent balance sheets. A trustee manages the underlying Bitcoin, which is held by a custodian, reducing counterparty risk.
Most physical Bitcoin ETPs trade on European exchanges. For instance, the CoinShares Physical Bitcoin ETP, listed on Nasdaq Stockholm, uses Komainu for custody. Komainu—founded by Nomura, Ledger, and CoinShares—provides institutional-grade security using hardware vaults and multi-party computation wallets. It is regulated by authorities in Jersey and Dubai, and proof of reserves is provided for transparency.
Key Differences Between ETFs and ETPs
While both spot Bitcoin ETFs and physical Bitcoin ETPs track Bitcoin’s price and hold the underlying asset, several distinctions are important for investors:
- Terminology and Regional Use: The term "ETF" is predominant in the U.S., while "ETP" or "ETC" is more common in Europe. "Spot" or "physical" denotes direct ownership of Bitcoin, as opposed to futures-based products.
- Settlement Methods: ETFs typically settle trades in cash (fiat currency), aligning with traditional market practices. ETPs often settle in Bitcoin, which can streamline processes, reduce costs, and lower counterparty risk.
- Regulatory Frameworks: U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs fall under SEC oversight and existing securities laws, while European physical ETPs are not bound by the Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities (UCITS) rules, allowing them to focus on single assets like Bitcoin. The EU’s Markets in Crypto Assets (MiCA) regulation provides additional clarity for crypto investments.
- Accessibility: ETFs are currently limited to U.S. markets, whereas physical ETPs are widely accessible in Europe and other regions.
👉 Explore more investment strategies
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main advantage of investing in a Bitcoin ETP or ETF?
These products offer a convenient way to gain Bitcoin exposure without the technical challenges of direct ownership, such as managing private keys or using crypto exchanges. They also provide regulatory oversight and institutional custody.
How do custodians ensure the safety of Bitcoin in these products?
Custodians use cold storage (offline wallets), multi-signature protocols, and regular audits by third-party firms to protect assets. Institutions like Coinbase and Komainu adhere to strict regulatory standards.
Are physical Bitcoin ETPs available to U.S. investors?
While physically-backed ETPs trade primarily in Europe, U.S. investors can access similar exposure through spot Bitcoin ETFs approved by the SEC. Always check availability based on your jurisdiction.
Can synthetic ETPs be as effective as physical ones?
Synthetic ETPs use derivatives to track Bitcoin’s price, which can introduce complexity and counterparty risk. Physical products are generally more transparent and straightforward for most investors.
How do regulatory differences impact these products?
Regulatory frameworks affect everything from custody requirements to investor protections. The EU’s MiCA regulation provides comprehensive rules for crypto assets, while the U.S. currently relies on adapting existing financial laws.
What should investors consider when choosing between an ETF and an ETP?
Key factors include fees, settlement methods, regulatory environment, and the reputation of the custodian. Investors should also consider their geographic location and access to specific markets.
Conclusion
Spot Bitcoin ETFs and physical Bitcoin ETPs both enable investors to participate in the cryptocurrency market through traditional brokerage accounts. While ETFs have recently gained attention in the U.S., ETPs have a longer track record in Europe. Understanding the differences in structure, settlement, and regulation can help investors make informed decisions based on their goals and risk tolerance. As the regulatory landscape evolves, these products will likely continue to play a crucial role in bridging traditional finance and digital assets.