The legal landscape surrounding cryptocurrency in China has been a topic of significant discussion, particularly after a recent statement from the Shanghai High Court. While the court clarified that personal possession of cryptocurrency is not illegal, this has led to questions about the legality of acquiring these digital assets. This article explores the current legal framework, common acquisition methods, and associated risks.
The Shanghai High Court Statement: What It Means
In a recent article, the Shanghai High Court explicitly stated that holding cryptocurrency as an individual is not illegal. This declaration was met with enthusiasm within the domestic crypto community, with many interpreting it as a sign of relaxed restrictions on virtual assets. However, it is crucial to understand that this statement does not represent a shift in policy but rather a reaffirmation of existing legal nuances.
Personal Possession: A Legal Gray Area
Chinese regulations have long indicated that personal possession of cryptocurrency occupies a gray area. Key policies, such as the 2021 "924 Notice" issued by the People's Bank of China and other regulatory bodies, classify virtual currency-related business activities as illegal financial activities. These include providing trading services, exchange services, and issuing virtual currencies. However, the notice does not explicitly prohibit individuals from holding cryptocurrency.
In practice, cryptocurrency is often treated as virtual property in legal contexts. For example:
- In 2019, a Hangzhou Internet Court ruled that Bitcoin possesses property attributes and qualifies as virtual property, supporting a plaintiff's claim for the return of illegally transferred Bitcoin.
- In 2021, a Shenzhen court recognized Litecoin (LTC) as virtual property in a specific case, ordering its return to the rightful owner.
This classification aligns cryptocurrencies with other virtual assets like in-game items or QQ coins, which can be legally held by individuals.
How Cryptocurrency Is Acquired and Its Legal Implications
While holding cryptocurrency may not be illegal, the methods of acquisition carry varying degrees of legal risk. Understanding these pathways is essential for navigating compliance.
1. Purchasing Cryptocurrency
Buying cryptocurrency is one of the most common acquisition methods. While the "924 Notice" does not explicitly label purchasing as illegal, it emphasizes that virtual currency transactions are not protected by law. This means individuals assume significant risk if transactions result in financial loss, as legal recourse may be limited.
Key considerations include:
- Using overseas exchanges may involve complexities related to foreign exchange management and tax reporting.
- Over-the-counter (OTC) transactions heighten risks due to anonymity and lack of第三方保障, increasing exposure to fraud or funds from illicit sources.
- Purchasing cryptocurrency with "black money" (funds obtained illegally) can lead to account freezes or legal scrutiny, even if the buyer is unaware of the funds' origins.
👉 Explore secure acquisition methods
2. Mining Cryptocurrency
Cryptocurrency mining, once a popular method for acquiring assets like Bitcoin, now faces stringent regulations. China's 2021 policy categorized mining as an eliminated industry, requiring the cleanup of existing projects and banning new ones. Large-scale mining operations are thus explicitly restricted.
For individuals, small-scale mining using personally owned equipment and legal electricity sources is not directly prohibited. However, risks arise from:
- Illegal electricity usage: Stealing power for mining can constitute theft or civil infringement.
- Unauthorized resource use: Utilizing others' computing resources without permission may lead to charges related to damaging computer information systems.
- Financial non-compliance: Mining proceeds linked to money laundering or tax evasion can result in legal consequences.
3. Investment Activities
Investing in projects that distribute tokens carries inherent risks. Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs) have been banned in China since 2017 due to their classification as illegal fundraising activities. Participating in ICOs may expose investors to losses without legal protection.
Venture capital (VC) investments in blockchain projects, where tokens are received as returns, also pose challenges:
- Projects may involve unlicensed securities offerings.
- Lack of transparency in token distribution can lead to disputes over valuations and investor rights.
4. Participating in Promotional Activities
Airdrops and referral rewards are common methods for acquiring cryptocurrency at low cost. While airdrops themselves are not illegal, they can be misused for illicit purposes, such as promoting fraudulent platforms or money laundering schemes.
Referral programs, especially those with multi-level rewards, may be classified as pyramid schemes if they involve three or more tiers of recruitment. Participation in such programs could lead to legal liability if they are deemed illegal.
👉 Learn about compliant investment strategies
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it legal to hold cryptocurrency in China?
Yes, personal possession of cryptocurrency is not illegal. However, it is considered virtual property rather than legal tender, and transactions are not protected by law.
What are the risks of buying cryptocurrency through OTC trades?
OTC transactions carry risks related to fraud, funds from illicit sources, and lack of legal recourse in case of disputes. Buyers should verify the legitimacy of funds and use reputable platforms.
Can individuals mine cryptocurrency in China?
Small-scale mining using legal electricity and personal equipment is not explicitly banned. However, large-scale operations are prohibited, and illegal practices like power theft can lead to severe penalties.
Are ICOs legal in China?
No, ICOs are classified as illegal fundraising activities and are strictly prohibited. Investors should avoid participating in such offerings.
What should I do if I receive cryptocurrency from an airdrop?
While receiving airdropped tokens is not illegal, ensure the project is legitimate and not involved in fraudulent activities. Avoid engaging further if promises of high returns seem suspicious.
How can I protect myself legally when dealing with cryptocurrency?
Maintain records of transactions, use compliant channels, and seek professional legal advice for complex issues like cross-border transactions or tax obligations.
Conclusion
The Shanghai High Court's statement reinforces that holding cryptocurrency is not illegal in China, but acquiring it involves navigating a complex web of regulations. Investors should prioritize compliance, choose legitimate channels, and avoid high-risk activities like ICOs or suspicious promotional schemes. Consulting legal professionals can provide additional safeguards in this evolving landscape. As the crypto industry continues to develop, staying informed and cautious is key to balancing innovation with regulatory adherence.