It's common advice to remove emotion from investing. Don't sell when you're scared, and don't buy when you're excited. While this is sound guidance, it's much harder to follow when you're in the midst of a crisis.
My most significant investing error occurred during the pandemic. I sold a portion of my stock investments out of fear, despite knowing better. This article shares my experience and the systems I've implemented to prevent similar mistakes.
The Emotional Challenge of Investing
Logically, we understand that emotional decisions often lead to poor investment outcomes. However, when faced with real-world stressors, logic can easily take a backseat to fear or excitement.
During stable periods, maintaining discipline seems straightforward. But when life becomes chaotic, our decision-making processes can become compromised.
My Pandemic Investing Mistake
When COVID-19 emerged, my rational thinking was overshadowed by fear. With four children suddenly home full-time and concerning health reports emerging daily, I made an emotional decision to sell investments.
I justified this move with logical reasoning: as a business owner with potentially uncertain cash flow, building a larger cash cushion seemed prudent. I sold both winners and losers to minimize tax implications, telling myself I was simply being responsible.
The truth was simpler: fear drove my decision. The combination of health concerns, family stress, and market volatility created a perfect storm of anxiety that overrode my better judgment.
Why Smart Investors Make Emotional Mistakes
Even experienced investors can fall prey to emotional decision-making under certain conditions. Several factors contributed to my pandemic-era mistake:
Simultaneous Life Stressors
During previous financial crises, including the Great Recession, I maintained my investment discipline. The key difference during the pandemic was that my personal life was simultaneously in turmoil.
With children home from school, concerns about elderly parents' health, and the general uncertainty of the situation, my capacity for rational financial decision-making was diminished.
The Illusion of Logical Justification
Emotional decisions often come dressed in logical clothing. I convinced myself that selling investments was a sensible precaution for a business owner during uncertain times.
This ability to rationalize emotional reactions makes them particularly dangerous for investors. We can always find seemingly reasonable explanations for fear-based decisions.
Market Timing Challenges
The stock market's recovery from the pandemic downturn was remarkably swift. While the crisis felt prolonged in daily life, the market impact was relatively brief. Those who sold during the panic often missed the subsequent recovery.
Systems to Prevent Emotional Investing Mistakes
Learning from this experience, I've implemented several strategies to protect against future emotional decisions:
Automate Investment Contributions
We maintain regularly scheduled contributions to both retirement and taxable investment accounts. This automated system has been in place for nearly twenty years and ensures consistent investing regardless of market conditions.
Automation removes the emotional component from regular investing decisions. By setting up systematic transfers, you ensure continuous participation in markets without requiring constant decision-making.
Establish Decision-Making Protocols
I now require consultation with my wife before making significant portfolio changes. For some investors, this might mean working with a financial advisor who can provide objective guidance during turbulent times.
Having a mandatory discussion before implementing major changes creates a natural pause that can prevent rash decisions. This extra step allows emotions to settle before taking action.
Conduct Thorough Needs Analysis
Before making portfolio changes, I now conduct a comprehensive review of our actual financial situation. This includes:
- Examining current spending patterns
- Reviewing emergency fund adequacy
- Assessing projected income needs
- Evaluating overall financial resilience
During the pandemic, I discovered we already had a year's worth of expenses in cash. Had I conducted this analysis first, I might have avoided selling investments unnecessarily.
Regularly Assess Risk Tolerance
I periodically review our asset allocation to ensure it aligns with our actual risk tolerance. While conventional wisdom suggests "120 minus age" for stock allocation, I've learned that personal comfort during market downturns matters more than theoretical models.
Using tools like net worth trackers helps maintain perspective on overall financial health rather than focusing exclusively on portfolio fluctuations.
Practice Delayed Decision-Making
When feeling pressured or panicked, I now implement a mandatory waiting period before making investment decisions. This simple practice of "slowing down" has prevented numerous potential mistakes.
The old adage "measure twice, cut once" applies perfectly to investing. Taking extra time to consider decisions rarely hurts and often helps avoid costly errors.
👉 Explore more investment strategies
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the most common emotional investing mistake?
The most frequent error is selling during market downturns out of fear. Investors often liquidate positions at market lows only to miss the subsequent recovery. This buy-high, sell-low pattern significantly damages long-term returns.
How can I recognize when I'm making an emotional investment decision?
Common signs include feeling urgency about a decision, seeking confirmation for a predetermined choice, or justifying actions with "this time is different" reasoning. Physical symptoms like anxiety or excitement can also indicate emotional decision-making.
What practical steps can I take to avoid emotional investing?
Establish automatic investment systems, implement a mandatory waiting period for significant decisions, and create a written investment plan to reference during turbulent times. These structured approaches help maintain discipline when emotions run high.
Should I change my investment strategy during market volatility?
Unless your fundamental financial situation has changed, market volatility alone rarely justifies strategy changes. Historically, maintaining a consistent approach through market cycles has produced better results than attempting to time the market.
How much cash should I keep to avoid panic selling?
Most financial advisors recommend maintaining 3-6 months of living expenses in emergency funds. Having adequate cash reserves reduces the likelihood that you'll need to sell investments during market downturns to cover unexpected expenses.
Can a financial advisor help prevent emotional decisions?
Yes, a good advisor provides objective guidance during turbulent markets and can help you stay committed to your long-term strategy. They serve as a behavioral coach during periods of market stress when emotions might otherwise drive decisions.
Conclusion
Emotional investing mistakes are common, even among experienced investors. The key is recognizing that we're all susceptible to fear and excitement-driven decisions, particularly during times of personal and market stress.
By implementing systems like automated investing, decision-making protocols, and regular financial reviews, you can build safeguards against emotional errors. Remember that successful investing is less about perfect timing and more about consistent discipline over time.
The market's recovery from the pandemic downturn demonstrated once again that staying invested through difficult periods typically rewards patience. While my emotional decision had limited financial impact thanks to other safeguards, it served as a valuable reminder that systems trump willpower when it comes to investment discipline.