The launch of nine Ethereum futures-based ETFs on U.S. exchanges in October 2023 marked a significant moment, offering investors a new way to gain exposure to Ethereum. Initial excitement, however, was met with surprisingly low trading volumes, raising questions about market sentiment and the future of cryptocurrency ETFs.
Initial Hype and Market Reaction
In the days leading up to the launch, traders attempted to front-run the news. This led to a notable increase in Ethereum futures open interest on centralized exchanges, which grew by $500 million—a 10% rise—and pushed the price of ETH above $1,700.
Despite this buildup, demand for the newly launched ETH futures ETFs failed to materialize. By midday on their first trading day, cumulative volume across all these products was less than $2 million. This tepid response contributed to a sell-off at the market’s open that Monday.
A Comparison with Bitcoin Futures ETF Launch
The trading volume, while reasonable for a typical ETF debut, paled in comparison to the launch of the first Bitcoin futures ETF, BITO. When BITO began trading in October 2021, Bitcoin was in a bull market, trading around $60,000. It achieved a staggering $200 million in volume within just the first 15 minutes.
The euphoria of that bull run undoubtedly played a major role in BITO’s success, making it an unrealistic benchmark. Nevertheless, it was clear that issuers had high hopes for their Ethereum futures products.
For instance, VanEck ran a marketing campaign called “EnterTheEther” to promote its EFUT ETF, even pledging to donate 10% of its profits to the Protocol Guild, a funding mechanism for Ethereum core contributors. Despite these efforts, EFUT was one of the more actively traded ETH funds but still saw less than $400,000 in volume on its first day.
Why the Lack of Interest?
Several factors contributed to the muted demand for these new ETFs. A primary reason is that they are futures-based products.
Unlike spot ETFs, which hold the actual underlying asset, futures ETFs invest in contracts that expire every 30 days. The process of “rolling” these contracts exposes investors to contango and backwardation effects. This means the price of the next month’s contract can be higher or lower than the expiring one, often making futures ETFs a less efficient way to track an asset’s price compared to spot products.
Beyond product structure, the limited demand seems to signal a broader cooling of interest in the cryptocurrency market. This observation has led some to reconsider the potential impact of a Bitcoin spot ETF approval.
A Bullish Case for Crypto ETFs
Despite the disappointing initial flows, the very approval of these ETH futures ETFs is a strong bullish signal for the entire cryptocurrency sector.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has long avoided clarifying Ethereum’s legal status. Its chairman, Gary Gensler, has repeatedly declined to answer direct questions from Congress on the matter. However, by approving these ETFs, the SEC appears to have implicitly reinforced the asset’s classification as a non-security.
This development has significant implications for spot ETFs. A recent court order compelled the SEC to revisit its rejection of Grayscale’s application to convert its Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) into a spot ETF. The court argued that a spot product is similar enough to the already-approved futures products that it should be treated likewise.
Some had worried the SEC might attempt to derail spot ETF approvals by de-listing Bitcoin futures ETFs. The approval of new crypto futures products makes such a move seem highly unlikely.
Furthermore, the SEC has finally begun engaging with applicants for Bitcoin spot ETFs—a shift from its previous pattern of dismissals. ETF insiders are growing increasingly optimistic about the chances of approval. This optimism now extends to Ethereum, especially after Grayscale filed to convert its Ethereum Trust (ETHE) into a spot ETF following the futures ETF news.
👉 Explore more on ETF investment strategies
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a spot ETF and a futures ETF?
A spot ETF holds the physical asset it tracks, like actual Bitcoin or Ethereum. A futures ETF holds contracts that derive their value from the future price of that asset. This often leads to less accurate tracking due to the costs and complexities of rolling over contracts.
Why was the trading volume for ETH futures ETFs so low?
The low volume can be attributed to a cooler crypto market compared to the 2021 bull run, the inherent complexities and costs of futures-based products, and a potential wait-and-see approach from investors anticipating spot ETFs.
Does the approval of an Ethereum futures ETF mean it’s not a security?
While not an explicit statement, the SEC’s approval is widely interpreted as a positive sign that the agency views Ethereum similarly to Bitcoin—as a commodity rather than a security. This is crucial for regulatory clarity.
What does this mean for a Bitcoin or Ethereum spot ETF?
The futures ETF approval sets a strong legal precedent. It reinforces the argument that approved futures products and proposed spot products are similar, making it much harder for the SEC to deny spot ETF applications without consistent reasoning. Approval seems more likely than ever.
Should I invest in a futures ETF?
For most long-term investors seeking direct exposure, a futures ETF is a more complex and often more expensive vehicle. Many are choosing to wait for the potential approval of more efficient spot ETFs.
When could a spot ETF be approved?
The process is ongoing. The SEC is now actively engaging with applicants for Bitcoin spot ETFs, and many analysts are optimistic for a decision in the near future. The same process is now beginning for Ethereum.
Conclusion
The launch of Ethereum futures ETFs may not have met volume expectations, but its significance is far greater than its first-day trading stats. The approval itself solidifies Ethereum's market position and creates a powerful precedent for the entire digital asset space. While futures ETFs might not be the ideal product for every investor, they pave a clear regulatory path for the ultimate goal: spot Bitcoin and spot Ethereum ETFs. Their approval now appears to be a question of "when," not "if."